- 18 new behavioral health study findings to know
- How 5 systems are embedding behavioral health into clinical care
- ‘Who watches the watchmen?’ CMS tightens oversight of accrediting bodies — 8 things to know
- 8 hospital projects worth $1B+ in 2026
- UnitedHealth, FTC near insulin rebates settlement
- The hidden disparity built into healthcare interoperability
- Christus consolidates inpatient services at Texas hospital
- Health AI regulation gaps span scribes, prior authorization: 5 notes
- Is cardiac catheterization the new cataract surgery?
- CMS floats permanent status for Medicare drug price negotiations: 5 things to know
- 13 cybersecurity updates for ASC leaders to know
- The safety issue hiding in ASC staffing
- Elevance sues former chief execution officer over noncompete agreement
- 15% of pregnant women report current alcohol use: CDC
- 15% of pregnant women report current alcohol use: CDC
- California healthcare district board member resigns to apply for CEO role
- Vermont regulators greenlight new ASC
- What surgeons don’t understand about anesthesia
- National Real Estate Advisors acquires Montana medical campus with ASC, MOB
- 5 ASC, ambulatory leaders from the biggest health systems
- Ohio dentist to retire after 34 years, close practice
- Good news, bad news for DSOs
- California Health Worker Union, Hospital Association Tout Dueling Ballot Initiatives
- Nearly 13,000 dental professionals needed to fill shortage areas: HRSA
- The states with the widest anesthesiologist salary spreads
- Optum Rx, FTC posed for settlement in insulin pricing case
- 7 new behavioral health projects representing nearly $1B in investment
- How the fastest-growing DSO is expanding its network
- Program closures, practice openings & more: 5 oral surgery updates 30 days
- CMS proposes permanent framework for Medicare drug price negotiations
- Dental hygienist pay up 21% since 2021
- ‘Making a bad situation worse’: 15% of psych beds lost in 4 California counties after staffing rule
- How dentist pay has evolved over the last 5 years
- Nearly 30% of Massachusetts residents filled behavioral health prescriptions
- Rhode Island Senate advances bill creating licensure pathway for foreign-trained dentists, hygienists
- The 10 states where physician assistant pay jumped the most
- Anesthesia stipends by the numbers
- SAMHSA unveils $40M behavioral health grant funding: 5 things to know
- Best, worst states for child well-being
- 5 dental school updates to know
- 7 DSOs making headlines
- Influencers, Booze And Teens: What's Showing Up In Their Feeds?
- Health 'War Room,' Digital Tools Are Tracking Disease Risks During World Cup
- Mercer survey: Employers eye cost-shifting strategies as health benefit spend rises
- Nvidia, Abridge collaborate to develop healthcare-specific AI model
- Industry Voices—Why health systems need physicians engaged in IT leadership
- FDA hearing on Amgen's Tavneos will include findings from an independent review
- In latest twist in Zepzelca saga, Jazz and PharmaMar lung cancer drug fails phase 3 test
- Food Labels and Restrictions Can Lower Childhood Obesity Rates, Study Finds
- Tourette Patients Face High Suicide Risk, Pain And Discrimination
- Have A Risk-Taking Teen? This Brain Chemical Might Be Responsible, Researchers Say
- Sepsis, Lung Infection Patients See No Benefit From Remote Monitoring
- Overlooked Social Connections Can Prevent Suicide
- 1 in 4 Covered California Enrollees Could Get State Aid Under Newsom Proposal
- Final Rules for Medicaid Work Requirements Are Out. Here’s What You Need To Know.
- Lilly, Biogen, Eisai and Genentech sponsor new ‘Let’s Talk Alzheimer’s’ podcast
- Fierce Pharma Asia—Astellas CEO’s 5-year plan; Takeda’s psoriasis win; RA’s China bridge program
- Why this behavioral health provider just bought a pharmacy
- Statement Regarding Minimum Pricing Increments and Access Fee Caps
- North Carolina awards $10M to expand rural behavioral healthcare access
- Healthcare costs poised to jump 9% in 2027 as health plans blame AI adoption, drug prices
- Provider groups file lawsuit against HHS over anti-trans Ryan White funding rules
- Genentech executes another round of layoffs, with 3 VPs axed
- Humana to sell off minority stake in end-of-life care provider Gentiva
- Vitamin C May Be Key To A Healthier Brain As You Age
- New Vaccine Schedule Released By American College of Obstetricians & Gynecologists
- AI use is surging across HHS, jumping 148% at the FDA in 2025, Bipartisan Policy Center data finds
- AI use is surging across HHS, jumping 148% at the FDA in 2025, Bipartisan Policy Center data finds
- Statement at the SEC Open Meeting on the Trade-Through Rule and Locked and Crossed Markets Provisions of Regulation NMS
- Disorder Protection Rule: Statement on the Proposed Amendments to Rule 611 and Other Provisions of Regulation NMS
- Statement on the Proposed Amendments to Regulation NMS
- Novo reports data breach, tells clinical trial patients to 'remain vigilant'
- ‘Not simply saving cost’: Inside Astellas CEO’s 5-year strategy to counter Xtandi’s patent cliff
- OIG: Frequent MA prior authorization denials for long-term care hospitals, inpatient rehab
- From Medicaid work requirement exemptions to AI safeguards in coverage: New AMA policies from annual meeting
- Joint initiative of 5 EU countries calls for 'unified approach' to pharma framework amid US drug pricing pressure
- J&J eyes rare disease expansion for blockbuster-to-be Imaavy with trial win
- Virtual care tech companies launch 'out-of-the-box' RPM tool for pharmacies
- Can Fasting Treat Gum Disease? Study Finds Reduced Inflammation
- Living With Cats Not Linked To Worse Asthma in Children
- Few Stroke, Brain Injury Survivors Get Top-Quality Hospital Rehab
- Popular Joint Pain Supplement, Glucosamine, Might Increase Alzheimer's Risk, Study Says
- Anguished Parents. Doctors In Tears. Utah's Long Measles Outbreak Takes A Toll.
- Madrigal takes giant inflatable liver on US tour in disease awareness push
- Listen to the Latest ‘KFF Health News Minute’
- Trump Bought Tobacco Stocks and Raked In Industry Donations as FDA Eased Standards
- Olixir NY teams with Crohn's & Colitis Foundation for ‘Spill Your Guts’ campaign
- Takeda’s TYK2 inhibitor beats Bristol Myers’ Sotyktu in phase 3 psoriasis showdown
- Hospital associations push CMS for higher 2027 pay bump, softer ramp-up for mandatory model
- AHIP 2026: Why Ascendiun CEO Paul Markovich is bullish on building out a digital health record for patients
- FDA’s Greenlight of Old Chemical Offers Chance To Restore Faith in Sunscreen
- Abridge picks up strategic investment from Eli Lilly, expands payer, research workflows
- Weekly Rundown: Karias Health launches AI companion; Mount Sinai, Wisp partner to expand PrEP access in NY
- Sugary Beverages May Raise Your Risk of Liver Cancer
- This Old House: Improving and Remodeling Our Registered Offering and Filer Status Regimes
- Ardent Health's surprise CEO change reflected need for margin focus amid headwinds, CFO says
- FDA Approves First New Sunscreen Ingredient, Bemotrizinol, in Two Decades
- Trustees expect Medicare Trust Fund's reserves to run out in 2033
- Vega Health licenses AI models from Parkland Center for Clinical Innovation to predict patient risks
- Eli Lilly yells ‘action’ on authentic patient portrayals at Tribeca Festival
- Teen Recovering From Concussion? A 'Sweet Spot' For Screen Time Could Speed Up Their Recovery
- Pfizer CEO Bourla reconsiders German investments as industry takes aim at healthcare reform plan: Reuters
- AMA issues policy urging exemptions in upcoming Medicaid work requirements
- Big Pharma-backed SonoThera sounds off with $125M series B for bubble-based genetic delivery
- Teva to lay off 250 at API unit as search for new owner drags on: report
- Women Hit Harder By Sleep Apnea Than Men, Study Finds
- Retro Video Game Aids Stroke Recovery, Improves Arm Function
- Experimental, Once-Daily GLP-1 Pill, Elecoglipron, May Offer New Option for Weight Loss, Diabetes
- Anguished Parents. Doctors in Tears. Utah’s Long Measles Outbreak Takes a Toll.
- Looming Medicaid Cuts Supercharge California’s Latest Labor-Industry Fight
- Genentech and Novartis dish up food allergy microdrama series
- ‘I’m a lot more optimistic today’: Mike Doustdar tells Fierce about pivotal first year as Novo Nordisk CEO
- Peirce Out: Remarks at the U.S. Chamber of Commerce Capital Markets Summit
- How Much Alcohol Is Actually Safe? A New Study Challenges Old Advice
- AbbVie’s Skyrizi narrowly slides ahead of J&J’s Tremfya in May drug ad spending rankings
- Air Pollution Might Contribute To Clogged Arteries, Heart Disease Risk
- New Study Suggests No Major Adverse Outcomes With Early GLP-1 Exposure During Pregnancy
- WuXi AppTec lands on Pentagon blacklist, facing Biosecure ban
- Merck, Gilead score in effort to develop the first weekly HIV pill
- Feeding Babies Eggs Sooner May Cut Allergy Risk, Study Suggests
- At A Tennessee Hospital, Nurse Stole Fentanyl And AI Missed It, State Records Say
- Infections A ‘Major Health Hazard’ For People With Diabetes, Large Study Warns
- MAHA's Treatments For Autism: Camel's Milk, Stem Cell Injections — And Spelling Therapy
- Could Your Kid Benefit From Counseling? Experts Offer 3 Questions To Help You Decide
- Trivia Nights, Valentine’s Cards: Overlooked Social Connections Can Prevent Suicide
- AI medical advice changes care decisions of most users: survey
- FDA Expands Sunscreen Options for the First Time in 20 Years
- Children's Well-Being Plummets Across 29 States, Report Finds
- Just 5 Minutes Of Prayer Helps Reduce Pain and Anxiety, Study Finds
- Medtronic Advances Hugo Robotic Surgery Platform with Key FDA Filings and Product Approvals
- Medtronic Advances Hugo Robotic Surgery Platform with Key FDA Filings and Product Approvals
- Medtronic Posts Strongest Revenue Growth in a Decade, Driven by Cardiovascular and Surgical Businesses
- Medtronic Posts Strongest Revenue Growth in a Decade, Driven by Cardiovascular and Surgical Businesses
- Boston Scientific Plans Indiana Distribution Center, 300 New Jobs
- Boston Scientific Plans Indiana Distribution Center, 300 New Jobs
- Irregular Sleep Risks Preschool Kids' Brain Power
- Why Alcohol Makes You Crave Salty Snacks — And How Protein-Rich Foods Can Help Prevent Weight Gain
- ADHD ‘Masking’ May Help People Blend In But Harms Mental Health
- Getting The RSV Shot, Abrysvo, While Pregnant Could Protect Your Baby After Birth
- Upcoming Billing Change Could Make Pregnancy Pricier
- Dengue Is No Longer Just A Travel Risk — What Google’s Mosquito Plan Could Mean For Your Summer
- Brain Surgery For Pituitary Tumor Helps Illinois Mom Have Second Baby
- Popular Blood Pressure Meds, Dihydropyridine Calcium-Channel Blockers, Linked To Kidney Damage Risk In Type 2 Diabetes
- Too Much Sitting In Pregnancy Doubles Risk Of Complications
- Spinal Cord Stimulation May Restore Arm Strength After Stroke
- “Harmonization: We’ll Have Lots to Talk About”
- Remarks at the Investor Advisory Committee Meeting
- A Quarter for Your Thoughts: Remarks at the Meeting of the SEC Investor Advisory Committee
- Remarks at the Investor Advisory Committee Meeting
- Base Case: Remarks at the IC3 Blockchain Camp
Michigan healthcare freedom community forum
Who gets to decide sincerity when it comes to 1st Amendment rights?
Standoff on COVID-19 vaccine ended a 22-year careerTim Rugg, an Ann Arbor firefighter for 22 years, says he was fired for refusing the COVID-19 vaccination after being refused a religious exemption. Rugg and three other Ann Arbor city employees have filed a civil lawsuit against the city. Rugg said the reason the city denied him a religious exemption is because the city determined his claim was not sincere.
Ann Arbor implemented a COVID-19 vaccination requirement in August 2021. Rugg said he submitted a religious exemption request shortly after but was refused on the grounds he was not sincere enough in his faith. He said he was suspended without pay in November 2021 and was terminated a month later during a meeting with human resources.
There was no other reason given for Rugg’s firing, according to Noah Hurwitz, his lawyer.
During the termination meeting, Rugg said, two union representatives, his lawyer, and his pastor attended, along with two of the city’s human resource employees.
Rugg’s union went to arbitration and the arbitrator said Ruggs had to undergo a second interview to determine his sincerity. The interview happened on May 15, 2023, with Rugg’s pastor present. Again, the city decided Rugg’s claim was not sincere.
Hurwitz said his law firm is taking on many similar cases. He believes that 98% of employers conducted themselves properly when it came to their COVID-19 policies, including granting exemptions. He also said that some clients say their employers acted inappropriately.
Hurwitz said the city of San Francisco was also sued after it fired employees for what it deemed insufficient sincerity. A district court judge ruled that the employees did not prove their sincere belief, and therefore ruled in favor of the city.
The 9th Circuit Court of Appeals heard an appeal. It remanded the case to the district court, with instructions to the judge to reevaluate the claims “applying the proper failure-to-accommodate inquiry.” The Ninth Circuit court ruled, “It seems that the district court erroneously held that Appellants had not asserted sincere religious beliefs because their beliefs were not scientifically accurate.”
The appeals court said that one’s religious beliefs do not have to be “consistent or rational” to be protected under Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964.
Bloomberg Law said employers who are hasty to deny a religious exemption “may run afoul of federal and state law, creating a liability for employers.”
Bloomberg said that an employee’s religious beliefs do not need to be consistently observed to be deemed sincere. The Equal Employment Opportunity Commission reports that “a sincere religious believer doesn’t forfeit his religious rights merely because he is not scrupulous in his observance, although ‘[e]vidence tending to show that an employee acted in a manner inconsistent with his professed religious belief is, of course, relevant to the factfinder’s evaluation of sincerity.’”
The city of Ann Arbor declined comment, citing the ongoing litigation.
Jamie A. Hope
Assistant Managing Editor of Michigan Capitol Confidential
Jamie A. Hope serves as the assistant managing editor of Michigan Capitol Confidential. She owns a consulting business, and previously worked at the Michigan Legislature as a legislative aide, as well as for the House Republican Policy Office. She is an author and has written for American Thinker and Human Events. Jamie has a bachelor’s degree in business administration from Michigan State University.
Jamie A. Hope may be reached at Hope@mackinac.org.
Newsweek: Religious exemption prevails in an EEOC case in Georgia.
Link to full report includes video.
Hospital Worker Fired for Not Getting Flu Shot Wins Payout
A hospital worker who was fired for refusing to get a shot of the flu vaccine has won a $45,000 payout from the facility he used to work for, according to a press release by the U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC).
The worker, who is unnamed in the press release dated December 22, had asked the hospital—Children's Healthcare of Atlanta, Inc. (CHOA)—in 2019 to be exempted from the facility's flu vaccination requirements based on "sincerely held religious beliefs," something which the hospital allows in its procedures.
Despite the fact that the hospital had already granted the same employee a religious exemption in 2017 and 2018, the following year CHOA denied his request and fired him. This happened despite the employee being a maintenance worker and having little interaction with the public or members of staff, according to the EEOC.
The former employee then filed a religious discrimination lawsuit against the CHOA thriough the federal agency in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Georgia, Atlanta Division, which eventually ruled in his favor.
The EEOC said that the reported conduct of the pediatric hospital "violated Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964, which prohibits firing an employee because of their religion and requires that employers reasonably accommodate the sincerely held religious beliefs of their employees."
The lawsuit will also change the way the hospital considers flu shot exemptions. According to the EEOC, CHOA will have to "presume the exemption eligibility of employees with remote workstations or who otherwise work away from the presence of other employees or patients, and to protect the ability of such employees to seek alternative positions within CHOA if their religious exemption request is denied."
The ruling also requires CHOA to train "relevant employees" on religious accommodation rights under Title VII.
Vaccine mandates are common for health workers, as they are considered to have an obligation towards their patients' safety. But mandatory vaccines have recently become a particularly contentious issue, especially after the COVID-19 emergency.
"It is the responsibility of an employer to accommodate its employees' sincerely held religious beliefs," said Marcus G. Keegan, the regional attorney for the EEOC's Atlanta District Office, in a written statement.
"Unless doing so would require more than a minimal cost, an employer may not deny requested religious accommodations, let alone revoke those previously granted without issue. The EEOC is pleased that the employee has been compensated and that CHOA has agreed to take steps to ensure that it meets its obligation to evaluate religious accommodation requests in a manner consistent with federal law."
https://www.newsweek.com/hospital-worker-fired-not-getting-flu-shot-wins-payout-1855724
MI Cap Con reports resolution of a benefits issue in the Ann Arbor case.
The EEOC civil rights suit appears to be ongoing in US District Court.
Ann Arbor firefighter wins appeal, receives unemployment benefits
Firefighter to get benefits after city fails to show at hearing
Former Ann Arbor firefighter Tim Rugg has won his appeal to receive unemployment benefits after the city fired him in December 2021. Michigan Capitol Confidential previously reported on Rugg’s dismissal, which came after 22 years of employment, for refusing a COVID-19 vaccination.
Rugg had requested a religious exemption from the vaccination mandate, which the city denied, saying he was insincere. The city then denied Rugg’s claim for unemployment benefits, citing misconduct under the Michigan Employment Security Act.
Rugg filed an appeal with the Department of Licensing and Regulatory Affairs. He won a reversal June 19 from Administrative Law Judge Denise McNulty.
Denise McNulty noted that courts have defined “misconduct” as actions that exhibit willful or wanton disregard of an employer’s interests, with an intent to do the employer harm, repeatedly. Rugg disputed the city’s claim he had acted that way. The city did not show up to the hearing McNulty conducted, leading her to rule in his favor. “His unrebutted and credible testimony contained no information of wrongdoing or disregard of the employer’s interest,” McNulty wrote. As a result, she concluded, “The claimant is not disqualified for benefits from the misconduct provision” of state law.
Rugg and three other city employees who were also denied religious exemptions have filed a civil lawsuit against Ann Arbor. They seek a monetary award, including payment for mental anguish and reimbursement for legal fees.
Rugg said his union’s lawyers have tried to negotiate with the city to reverse his termination and reinstate him but have not succeeded.
The city did not respond to an email seeking comment.
Get MHF Insights
News and tips for your healthcare freedom.
We never spam you. One-step unsubscribe.




















