- ASCs’ vendor problem
- Providence’s physician chief on its ‘holistic’ approach to value-based care
- What the Health? From KFF Health News: A New CDC Nominee, Again
- States Update Guardianship Laws To Keep Children of Immigrants Out of Foster Care
- Anesthesia job market faces ‘major disruption’
- Florida system raises $100M for new ED
- North Carolina system names COO
- Mark Cuban wants to bring drug manufacturing to hospitals’ doorsteps — literally
- UCI Health names chief AI officer
- Nevada hospital names CEO
- Saint Luke’s taps president for 2 hospitals
- Dental community mourns dentist killed in murder-suicide
- Mass General Brigham, CVS deal could raise healthcare spending $40M annually: Report
- Ideal Dental opens 1st Oklahoma practice, expands in 2 more states
- PDS Health eyes the next era of medical-dental integration
- Mark Cuban dives into direct contracting
- HCA executive pay by the numbers
- Iris Telehealth offers behavioral health analytics platform
- HHS names chief economist, regulatory leader to address healthcare affordability
- Loma Linda University Health names new president
- The best ASCs for colonoscopy, endoscopy in the South: US News
- Tennessee moves forward with CON repeal
- Dental schools take action to alleviate workforce shortages: 6 updates
- American Medical Group Association partners with Talkiatry to expand psych access
- Trump nominates CDC director
- ChristianaCare, Cardiovascular Physicians of Delaware to open joint venture ASC
- 5 states regulating AI in mental health
- Centerstone debuts $13M youth behavioral health campus in Missouri
- 3 DSOs making headlines
- Maine restricts noncompetes for rural healthcare workers
- Heartland Dental opens Florida office
- The 10 biggest ASC deals of the last 5 years
- 10 dental Medicaid updates to know from Q1
- White House eyes ibogaine research expansion
- New Weight Loss Research Questions Need for GLP-1 Drugs
- Trump Names CDC Director Pick
- Rising Colon Cancer Deaths Hit Younger Adults Without Degrees Hardest
- FDA To Review Whether To Allow More Access To Certain Peptides
- SocialRx teams up with FQHC in NYC to prescribe arts and culture for chronically ill patients
- The Healthccare Burnout Backlask (pt 4): Why Contract Negotiation Has Become a Core Strategic Skill for Healthcare Administrators
- The Healthccare Burnout Backlask (pt 4): Why Contract Negotiation Has Become a Core Strategic Skill for Healthcare Administrators
- Industry Voices—DOJ jumps into 340B cases over state law, raising questions about federal plans for the program
- Most People Would Take A Blood Test For Alzheimer's, Study Says
- FDA's accelerated approval pathway needs stronger transparency, evidence standards: ICER
- Memory Problems? Your Salt Intake Could Make Matters Worse, Study Says
- Ultra-Processed Foods Linked To Fatty Muscles, Potential Knee Arthritis
- This Sexually Transmitted Infection Linked To Heart Attack, Stroke
- New Depression Treatment Matches ECT with Less Memory Loss, Study Says
- How Playtime at Age 2, Especially with Parents, Shapes Teen Fitness Habits
- Your New Therapist: Chatty, Leaky, and Hardly Human
- Teva scores in appeal as court revives $177M verdict against Lilly in migraine patent spat
- Listen: With Little Federal Regulation, States Are Left To Shape the Rules on AI in Health Care
- Fierce Pharma Asia—Astellas’ stem cell therapy rethink; GSK’s bullish ADC plan; Daiichi’s OTC sale
- BIO comes out swinging with 'Fight of Our Lives' campaign for the industry’s 50th birthday
- The future of medical-dental integration is here
- Texas dentist has license suspended
- Efforts grow to limit corporate dental ownership, protect dentist autonomy: 6 updates
- What’s the deal with insurer mental health parity violations?
- Remarks at the Options Market Structure Roundtable
- Wider care gaps predicted as mental health parity rule faces rollback
- Sheppard Pratt gets $16.5M for behavioral health expansion
- Former Deputy Surgeon General Erica Schwartz, M.D., nominated as CDC director
- Verily Health simplifies medical jargon alphabet soup with AI-powered app in new campaign
- 10 trends in behavioral health usage: Report
- Cattywampus: Statement on the CAT Concept Release
- Providers' advantage on out-of-network billing disputes likely to continue: Capstone
- Butterflies and Condors: Remarks at the Options Market Roundtable
- Viatris, Teva kick off separate recalls over dissolution, raw material issues
- Mental health ED visits at Children’s Hospital Colorado jump 20% in April
- Rising ACA Costs Leave Many Unable To Pay for Coverage
- One Lot of Xanax Recalled Nationwide Over Quality Issue, FDA Says
- Cough Drops From Several Brands Being Recalled, FDA Says
- CDC May Get New Leader as Officials Consider Erica Schwartz
- Statement at the Roundtable on Options
- Opening Remarks at the Options Market Structure Roundtable
- APA launches resource library for trusted digital mental health tools
- E-Bikes And E-Scooters A Growing Menace On City Streets, Study Says
- 'Absent or trivial' effects: Anti-amyloid Alzheimer's drugs called into question once again
- RFK Jr. kicks off string of congressional hearings to talk White House budget plan
- This Simple Step Could Improve The Benefits From Your Regular Workouts
- New Alzheimer's Drugs Provide No Meaningful Benefit, Major Evidence Review Concludes
- Air Pollution and Weather Tied to Migraines
- Study Says Stress, Weight And Hormones Alter Timing of Puberty in Girls
- Why Walking Remains Unsteady After Partial Spinal Cord Injury
- Roche to launch another Elevidys study after EU rejection of Duchenne gene therapy
- Lilly answers FDA's call for more Foundayo safety info, plotting diabetes filing in parallel
- As US Birth Rate Falls, Feds’ Response May Make Pregnancy More Dangerous
- New Federal Medicaid Rules Require One Month of Work. Some States Demand More.
- Omnicom brews Olixir from FCB Health, rebranding storied agency after Interpublic takeover
- DiMe-led initiative brings together pharma, virtual providers, digital pharmacies to develop blueprint for DTC pharma models
- UPDATED: Heeding RFK Jr.'s call, FDA reclassifies 12 unapproved peptides ahead of advisory committee meeting
- Carrot launches proprietary AI platform for personalized fertility, family care
- UC Health workers plan open-ended, system-wide strike for May 14
- Baylor Scott & White Health Plan to depart individual market, Medicaid this year
- In industry's latest OTC pivot, Daiichi Sankyo lines up $1.5B consumer health unit sale to beverage giant Suntory
- EPA Delays Decisions on 'Forever Chemicals'
- Wildlife Trade Tied To Higher Risk of Diseases Spreading to Humans
- Yes, This is the Worst Pollen Season Ever — Until Next Year
- GoodRx launches 7.2-mg Wegovy dose for self-pay patients at $399 per month
- Providers back bipartisan bill eliminating Medicare chronic care management cost sharing
- Progyny unveils new fertility benefit option for small, mid-size employers
- New Weight Loss Pill, Foundayo, Gets Approval But FDA Seeks More Safety Data
- Seqster launches new data tool to turn clinical sites into 'research-ready data collection points'
- Gilead widens global Yeztugo access agreement, but MSF says supply is 'not nearly enough'
- Novartis CEO Vas Narasimhan joins Anthropic’s board as biopharma’s ties to AI deepen
- Behavioral health utilization is up with anxiety disorders leading demand, report finds
- Does Your Child Have A Concussion? These Are The Signs, Review Says
- AI Reveals Negative Labels in Medical Records for Sickle Cell Patients
- 'Food-as-Medicine' Improves Life for Heart Failure Patients
- Silent Heart Rhythm Problem Might Triple Risk Of Heart Failure In Seniors
- Blood Test Predicts Alzheimer's Years Before Symptoms, Brain Changes
- An Infectious Combo Triples Risk Of MS, Study Says
- Astellas manufacturing chief views reliable supply, bridging research as his production 'north star'
- Physician compensation up 3% in 2025, but not all specialties saw raises: Medscape
- Pfizer recruits former Angel Lucy Liu for latest mission against cancer
- Teva launches new online schizophrenia community project
- One man’s journey from gambling addiction to recovery and advocacy
- Rural Nebraska Dialysis Unit Closes Despite the State’s $219M in Rural Health Funding
- Medi-Cal Immigrant Enrollment Is Dropping. Researchers Point to Trump’s Policies.
- Ionis exec shares method to the Madness after 2026 Drug Name Tournament win
- Abridge expands clinical decision support solution with UpToDate partnership, new NEJM, JAMA content tie-ups
- Travere maps course for Filspari's $3B US opportunity after landmark rare disease nod
- Hospitals with more disadvantaged patients fall short on price transparency, study finds
- FDA tells Eli Lilly to round up more safety info on key obesity launch Foundayo
- Meat Consumption Rises as Protein Trend Grows, Experts Warn
- Bill would force payers to apply DTC drug purchases to patient deductibles
- Bill would force payers to apply DTC drug purchases to patient deductibles
- Nuts.com Recalls 10,000+ Pounds of Candy Over Allergy Risk
- Listen to the Latest ‘KFF Health News Minute’
- Estados cambian leyes para evitar que hijos de inmigrantes detenidos entren al sistema de cuidado temporal
- Keebler Health secures $16M in series A funding for AI-powered risk adjustment platform
- Sam’s Club Recalls Children’s Pajamas Due to Fire Hazard
- Small Talk? It May Be Better Than You Think
- Anthem, Mount Sinai reach contract agreement, restore in-network coverage
- J&J, chasing $100B year, sports immunology ‘dual powerhouse’ of Tremfya and new launch Icotyde
- Stanford Health Care, Alameda Health System partner to support St. Rose Hospital
- Long-Term Opioid Prescriptions Fall By About A Quarter
- Gut Bacteria Might Drive Rare Food Allergy in Children, Study Finds
- Stents Can Ease Long-Term Symptoms Of Deep Vein Thrombosis, Trial Shows
- Young Cancer Survivors Face Doubled Risk Of Subsequent New Cancer
- Does Your Child Have Nightmares? Here's One Solution
- Marriage's Hidden Benefit? A Lower Risk Of Cancer
- Novo taps OpenAI to deploy AI across R&D, manufacturing and corporate functions
- Pfizer rebuked by FDA for misleading Adcetris ads on Facebook
- FDA Reminds More Than 2,200 Sponsors and Researchers to Disclose Trial Results
- FDA Reminds More Than 2,200 Sponsors and Researchers to Disclose Trial Results
- Freedom of Associations
- Interfacing with our Inner Demons: Comments on the Division of Trading and Markets' Statement on Certain User Interfaces
- Staff Statement Regarding Broker-Dealer Registration of Certain User Interfaces Utilized to Prepare Transactions in Crypto Asset Securities
- Statement Regarding Staff No-Action Letter to Bank of England
Breathless story in Michigan Advance about private equity firm ownership of home health care operations. They cover a firm in Alabama with the implication that such ownership may become common in Michigan. This, of course, is a direct result of all the stimulus monies printed by the Federal government. They all wind up in the hands of the ultra wealthy, who have to invest those dollars or lose them in our inflationary environment (which is also due to the massive Federal budget deficits):
Private equity’s growing footprint in home health care draws scrutiny
BY: Anna Claire Vollers - February 20, 2024HUNTSVILLE, Ala. — Help at Home employed nearly 800 caregivers scattered across every county in Alabama, helping 1,100 older and disabled clients with activities such as bathing, housework and meal preparation.
And then suddenly, it was gone.
Alabama’s largest provider of home care services said it abruptly left the state last fall because the state’s “reimbursement and regulatory environment” made it difficult to recruit and retain enough workers, according to Kristen Trenaman, the company’s vice president of public relations. Its departure sent state agencies scrambling to find new caregivers for the people who relied on it.
Help at Home’s departure from Alabama “had a significant effect,” according to Debra Davis, deputy commissioner for the Alabama Department of Senior Services. Davis said her agency worked with former Help at Home clients to find replacements on the fly.
Help at Home, owned by private equity firms Centerbridge Partners and Vistria Group, continues to provide in-home and community-based care in a dozen other states, with 49,000 caregivers and 66,000 monthly clients. It’s been aggressively expanding outside Alabama, acquiring home care companies and posting thousands of job openings on its website. Neither firm responded to Stateline’s request for comment.
Proponents of private equity investment in health care say the infusion of capital helps smaller companies expand into new markets, streamline their costs and pay for new technology.
But critics point to Help at Home’s departure from Alabama as a cautionary tale for what can happen when states that spend little on health care rely on private equity-owned providers to care for their most vulnerable residents.
Private equity-owned health care companies are focused on generating robust profits for investors. Typically, they want to cut costs, increase cash flow, use debt to fund expansion and then sell within a few years for maximum profit. In health care, critics say, that business model can diminish the quality of care, increase costs and narrow access for patients — particularly in more lightly regulated industries such as home care and hospice care.
“We leave a lot to the whims of the market and allow private players to dictate access to and quality of health care, and the case of Help at Home is a great example of that,” said Mary Bugbee, senior research and campaign coordinator for health care at the Private Equity Stakeholder Project, a research and advocacy group.
“At the end of the day it’s about money, and if we don’t have guardrails in our policies to prevent these pullouts, they’re going to keep happening.”
Private equity firms pool investments from pension funds, endowments, sovereign wealth funds and wealthy individuals to buy controlling stakes in companies. They’ve drawn increasing legislative scrutiny and public outrage as they’ve grown their footprint in U.S. health care companies.
And while much of that negative attention has focused on hospitals and nursing homes, many private equity firms also have turned their sights to the lucrative and less regulated home health care industry.
“There are favorable demographic trends in the aging population that’s only going to keep getting older,” Ankeet Patel, a vice president at private equity firm Shore Capital Partners, told the audience at the Home Health Care News Capital + Strategy Conference in April 2023. “Pair that with home-based settings being cost-effective and the preferred setting for people that receive care, and that creates a lot of opportunity.”
Around 10,000 baby boomers turn 65 every day. By 2030, 1 in 5 Americans will be over age 65, the largest share in U.S. history. That’s tens of millions of people who will need care in the coming years, and most older adults say they would prefer to age in their homes, rather than in a nursing home, for as long as possible.
As long-term care for older adults moves away from nursing homes and toward home care, private equity is following close behind.
Increasing demand
Home care can mean a variety of things. Home health is often the term for more skilled care provided by licensed nurses and therapists, including wound care and medication management. Personal home care typically refers to nonclinical services from professional aides, such as help bathing and dressing, or performing household chores that might include cleaning, cooking and laundry.
It’s not just aging consumers who prefer home care to nursing homes: Insurance payers like it too. For both public and private insurance, It’s a potential cost-saver for people who don’t need round-the-clock supervision.
Monthly costs for in-home care average about $5,000 for 40+ hours per week, compared with $8,000-$9,000 at a nursing home, according to the most recent Cost of Care Survey from insurance company Genworth. The survey is cited by agencies including the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services.
But costs vary widely from state to state. In Mississippi, in-home care averages around $3,800 monthly, while a private room in a nursing home is nearly twice that, about $7,300 per month. In Massachusetts, in-home care is nearly $6,000 monthly while a private nursing home room is more than $13,500 a month.
For those who need 24/7 care, home health is far less economical, averaging around $19,000 per month, more than twice the cost of a private room in a nursing home.
A 2019 analysis of Medicare claims found total costs 90 days after an emergency department visit were lower for patients treated at home versus those treated in the hospital. The home health patients also had lower hospital readmissions.
As consumer demand increases and insurance giants such as Humana and UnitedHealth Group wade into the market with their own home health agencies, private equity continues to gobble up smaller home health companies, consolidating them into regional networks. From 2018 to 2019, private equity was involved in nearly half of home health care industry deals.
At the end of the day it’s about money, and if we don’t have guardrails in our policies to prevent these pullouts, they’re going to keep happening.
– Mary Bugbee, senior research and campaign coordinator for health care at the Private Equity Stakeholder Project
Piling on debt
Private equity firms typically aim to acquire a company and boost profits before selling it within five to seven years. They often purchase companies with borrowed money, using the company’s assets as collateral for the loans.
Help at Home’s private equity owners, Centerbridge Partners and Vistria Group, partially funded their 2020 purchase of the company by loading it with $745 million in debt. Now, Help at Home — and not its private equity owners — must pay off the debt and interest, which can leave it less able to turn a healthy profit in a state such as Alabama with low Medicaid reimbursement rates.
Piling debt onto a company to finance additional purchases or to pay investors a dividend is a private equity hallmark. The industry tends to use debt more recklessly than publicly traded companies that must be more transparent about their financials, said Bugbee, of the Private Equity Stakeholder Project. Plus, there’s an attitude of high risk, high reward.
A private equity-owned company struggling under high debt payments might make the business decision to unload its services in one state while expanding in a state that can better help the business stay afloat, Bugbee said.
Extra debt can leave a company more financially vulnerable and more likely to look for less-profitable service lines to cut, said Michael Fenne, senior coordinator for health care at the Private Equity Stakeholder Project.
“This is a good example of the extent that private equity can shape the health care landscape in a state,” Fenne said of Help at Home’s abrupt departure from Alabama. “They can do that in different ways; sometimes it’s cutting staff, sometimes it’s shedding real estate.
“What stood out about this situation is that they went beyond any of those more mitigated measures toward a complete removal from the state.”
A high percentage of Help at Home’s revenue came from Medicare and Medicaid, leaving it vulnerable to regulatory changes and state budget challenges, according to a 2022 report from Moody’s Investors Service, a credit rating agency.
“It’s possible [for a business] to make money from Medicaid, even from low reimbursement rates, but if you have a business that’s saddled with debt it’s going to be a lot harder to do that,” Bugbee said.
Trenaman, of Help at Home, told Stateline that the decision to exit Alabama wasn’t made lightly.
“We take our responsibility to provide the safest, in-home personal care services to our clients very seriously,” she said in an email. “Taking that responsibility into account, we believe we had no choice but to make that very difficult decision not to renew our annual contracts effective September 30, 2023.”
Alabama’s Medicaid policies for in-home care made it difficult to hire and retain employees, she said, “and we have not been able to overcome these challenges in the state of Alabama.”
Alabama is one of 10 states that has not accepted federal funding to expand eligibility for Medicaid coverage to people making up to 133% of the federal poverty level. The state has some of the stingiest income-based eligibility requirements in the country.
Help at Home also operates in Florida, Georgia and Mississippi, none of which has expanded Medicaid. In the year or so before its Alabama exit, Help at Home purchased home care companies in Georgia, Indiana, New York, Ohio and Pennsylvania. As of late January, it had about 2,700 open jobs on its website, most of them for caregivers.
But Alabama does have especially low Medicaid reimbursement rates for home care services. The state reported paying home health agencies just $27 per day for each Medicaid client receiving care, according to KFF, a health policy research organization, though it did not share its rates for in-home personal care. Its home health reimbursement is the lowest daily rate for home health agencies out of the 26 states that reported their numbers to KFF.
Texas and Wyoming, which also have not expanded Medicaid, reimburse home health agencies about $181 and $58 per visit or per day, respectively.
“Medicaid and a state’s failure to expand it is definitely a valid reason a business might struggle,” said Bugbee. “But there are analogous examples of private equity-owned health care companies that will pull out of some states and not others because at the end of the day, it’s about their bottom line.”
Potential for regulation
Since private equity functions similarly across the health care sphere, state and federal laws that were spurred by private equity’s involvement in hospital systems and other health care sectors also could work for home health agencies.
Last year, 24 states enacted laws related to health system consolidation and competition, according to the National Conference of State Legislatures, an advisory think tank for lawmakers.
“The change of ownership [of companies owned or being acquired by private equity] is a window of time that regulators can use to really look into a business and who’s acquiring it,” Bugbee said. “If they do their due diligence, it can go a long way toward protecting patients and workers.”
Improving transparency, requiring certain health care staff-to-patient ratios and boosting wages for health care workers can also help protect patients and communities.
This year California will begin enforcing a 2022 law that requires health care providers to notify the state of major financial transactions, including mergers and acquisitions. In January, New York increased minimum wages for home health care workers to $17.55-$18.55, depending on the region. Those wages will continue to rise annually through 2026.
Efforts to enact new rules often lag a few years behind, as policymakers want to see evidence of harm to workers or patients before enacting changes.
“But after watching private equity investments play out in health care for decades,” Bugbee said, “we do know enough about how private equity typically operates that there are still ways regulators and policymakers can be proactive.”
Sixty day public comment period opened in a multi agency inquiry into private equity ownership of health care providers:
The Federal Trade Commission, the Department of Justice’s (DOJ) Antitrust Division, and the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) jointly launched a cross-government public inquiry into private-equity and other corporations’ increasing control over health care.
Private equity firms and other corporate owners are increasingly involved in health care system transactions, and, at times, those transactions may lead to a maximizing of profits at the expense of quality care. The cross-government inquiry seeks to understand how certain health care market transactions may increase consolidation and generate profits for firms while threatening patients’ health, workers’ safety, quality of care, and affordable health care for patients and taxpayers.
The agencies issued a Request for Information (RFI) requesting public comment on deals conducted by health systems, private payers, private equity funds, and other alternative asset managers that involve health care providers, facilities, or ancillary products or services. The RFI also requests information on transactions that would not be reported to the Justice Department or FTC for antitrust review under the Hart-Scott-Rodino Antitrust Improvements Act.
“When private equity firms buy out healthcare facilities only to slash staffing and cut quality, patients lose out,” said FTC Chair Lina M. Khan. “Through this inquiry the FTC will continue scrutinizing private equity roll-ups, strip-and-flip tactics, and other financial plays that can enrich executives but leave the American public worse off.”
“Preserving competition in health care markets is a priority for the Department of Justice because of its important impact on the health and well-being of Americans,” said Assistant Attorney General Jonathan Kanter of the Justice Department’s Antitrust Division. “This RFI will enable the agencies to accurately understand the modern market realities of the health care industry and forcefully enforce the law against unlawful deals. Hearing from patients, workers, and market participants will be critical in developing future enforcement and policy efforts relating to consolidation in the health care sector.”
“Increasing competition in health care markets gives people more choices. Competition helps ensure patients have access to high-quality, lower cost care, and that health care workers receive higher pay and work under better conditions. And it saves taxpayers money,” said Health and Human Services Secretary Xavier Becerra. “We need to do more to understand the impact of private equity and corporate dealmaking on our policymaking, regulatory decisions and enforcement actions. The Biden-Harris Administration is committed to improving transparency and competition in health care.”
Research has shown that competition in health care provider and payer markets promotes higher quality, lower cost health care, greater access to care, increased innovation, higher wages, and better benefits for health care workers. Comments submitted in response to the joint RFI will inform the agencies’ enforcement priorities and future action, including potential regulations aimed at promoting and protecting competition in health care markets and ensuring appropriate access to quality, affordable health care items and services.
The agencies’ RFI builds upon the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services’ recent RFI on Medicare Advantage and a RFI issued by the FTC and HHS on how pharmaceutical middleman groups may be contributing to drug shortages. The RFI issued today stems from a December 2023 announcement outlining efforts by the DOJ, FTC and HHS to lower health care and drug costs, while promoting competition to benefit patients and health care workers.
In addition to the launch of the RFI, all three agencies will also be participating today in a virtual public workshop that will explore the impact of private equity in health care and will discuss what the federal government is doing to address any harmful effects.
All market participants—including patients, consumer advocates, doctors, nurses, health care providers and administrators, employers, insurers, and more—are invited to share their comments in response to the RFI. The agencies seek comments on a variety of transactions, including those involving dialysis clinics, nursing homes, hospice providers, primary care providers, hospitals, home health agencies, home- and community-based services providers, behavioral health providers, as well as billing and collections services.
The public will have 60 days to submit comments at Regulations.gov, no later than May 6, 2024. Once submitted, comments will be posted to Regulations.gov.
The Federal Trade Commission develops policy initiatives on issues that affect competition, consumers, and the U.S. economy. Follow the FTC on social media, read consumer alerts and the business blog, and sign up to get the latest FTC news and alerts.
Get MHF Insights
News and tips for your healthcare freedom.
We never spam you. One-step unsubscribe.














