- Study Links High Antioxidant Intake To Changes in Offspring Development
- The Healthcare Burnout Backlash (pt 1): Burnout Reaches Well Beyond Clinicians
- The Healthcare Burnout Backlash (pt 1): Burnout Reaches Well Beyond Clinicians
- Even Mild Oxygen Loss in Preemies' First Hours Poses Lifelong Brain Risks: Study
- 12 oral surgery updates in 2026
- 5 ASC, MOB deals in California
- Hidden OR capacity challenges: 8 perioperative leaders on what’s draining surgical time
- The Aspen Group’s 3-year growth recap: 40 moves
- Florida State University set to acquire Tallahassee hospital
- How Confusing Financial Journeys Undermine Revenue and Trust
- How Confusing Financial Journeys Undermine Revenue and Trust
- Misalignment, Not Malice: Rethinking Generational Conflict in Healthcare
- If AI ‘adds friction, it fails’: How Mayo Clinic scales technology
- As maternity units close, AdventHealth restores OB care in rural Kansas
- Oklahoma officials warn of new opioid
- The new metrics of healthcare technology ROI: What matters to healthcare leaders
- Hoag to launch transplant center in 2027
- MercyOne hospital to transition labor and delivery services
- MercyOne hospital to transition labor and delivery services
- Southeast metros lead US population growth as national gains slow
- 8 Medicare Advantage numbers to know in 2026
- 17 Senate Dems push back on 2027 ACA proposal
- Providence hospital closes inpatient pediatric unit
- Michigan finalizes Medicaid mental health assessment policy changes
- 10 financial notes on USPI’s growth over the past 3 years
- 15 new orthopedic practice, center openings in Q1
- The oral surgery technological revolution
- From Anxiety to Action: How Ambulatory Leaders Are Rebuilding Margins in 2026
- Where GI training may fall short
- What it took to become the world’s first ASC to offer Stryker’s robotic knee tech
- Medtronic’s win in spinal cord stimulator lawsuit upheld
- How the Trump Administration Uses Migrant Kids To Find and Detain Family Members
- Heartland Dental’s 3-year growth recap: 30+ moves
- Cencora’s $10B+ physician acquisition spree: A breakdown
- Tennessee physician practice acquired
- The FTC is coming for healthcare consolidation: 10 things physicians need to know
- Adventist Health sees momentum from insourcing revenue cycle operations
- Oral GLP-1s, COVID preventatives: 3 more drugs in the pipeline, Optum says payers should watch
- Unlicensed dentistry cases, DSO deals, legislation & more: 10 dentistry updates in Virginia
- Providence trims 2025 operating loss to $132M, notches second consecutive quarter of gains
- Missouri system debuts mobile behavioral health unit
- Yale researchers study GLP-1’s potential for SUD
- Texas dental school receives $6.5M to expand pediatric dental, medical programs
- North Carolina autism provider to expand therapy access
- $3M Verdict Links Social Media to Anxiety and Depression
- West Virginia hospital to end OB delivery services
- 6 DSOs making headlines
- California hospital’s finances improve, cash position remains ‘dire’
- 1 in 5 metro markets face inpatient monopoly: 7 notes
- Minnesota system faces uncertainty amid Medicare delays
- Ohio county approves behavioral health crisis center plan
- The White House Delays CDC Pick
- New COVID 'Cicada' Variant Is Spreading — What Experts Want You To Know
- Advocate Health to launch ‘nation’s largest’ hospital drone delivery program in Zipline partnership
- Op-ed: Empathy meets efficiency—how the responsible use of AI can transform Medicare
- Family Caregivers Provide $1 Trillion In Annual Labor, AARP Says
- ‘Health Doesn’t Need to Be Ludacris’: Bayer signs rapper-actor to multivitamin campaign
- Rocket plots measured trajectory for new gene therapy Kresladi after clearance to launch from FDA
- Healthy Lab Results May Mask Future Risks for Kids with Obesity
- At-Home Chemotherapy Is Safe, Feasible, Pilot Study Indicates
- What You Do While Sitting Could Predict Dementia Risk
- New Cholesterol Guidelines: What Patients and Caregivers Need to Know
- Want A Bootlicking Yes Man? Ask An AI Chatbot For Advice, Study Warns
- Specially Coated Implants Better For Breast Cancer Patients, Study Finds
- Trump Team Claims Successes Against ACA Fraud While Pushing for More Controls
- Give and Take: Federal Rural Health Funding Could Trigger Service Cuts
- Fierce Pharma Asia—Takeda’s $1.3B reorg; India’s GLP-1 floodgates; Gilead’s $2.2B buy of a China NewCo
- Where are you with EUDAMED?
- Where are you with EUDAMED?
- HL7 Launches Real‑Time Medical Device Interoperability Accelerator
- HL7 Launches Real‑Time Medical Device Interoperability Accelerator
- Two GA Tech ATDC Startups — Nephrodite and OrthoPreserve — Secure FDA Breakthrough Device Designation
- Two GA Tech ATDC Startups — Nephrodite and OrthoPreserve — Secure FDA Breakthrough Device Designation
- Artificial Intelligence: ROI, not Clinical Autonomy, Leads Operational Workflows
- Artificial Intelligence: ROI, not Clinical Autonomy, Leads Operational Workflows
- Medtronic and Merit Medical Systems distribution agreement for new, ViaVerte basivertebral nerve ablation system
- Medtronic and Merit Medical Systems distribution agreement for new, ViaVerte basivertebral nerve ablation system
- Breakthrough Device Designation for Noah Labs Vox Heart Failure Detection Device
- Breakthrough Device Designation for Noah Labs Vox Heart Failure Detection Device
- Why private practice dentistry needs a better model
- CareQuest Innovation Partners, Kno2 collab on medical-dental data integration
- Nonprofit highlights rural opioid care strategies
- Vitana Pediatric & Orthodontic Partners adds Florida practice
- What the Health? From KFF Health News: A Headless CDC
- 20 behavioral health leaders challenge industry assumptions
- Recordati confirms it's weighing CVC Capital buyout offer of $12.6B
- 3 California behavioral health centers to close amid funding shifts
- Nonprofit celebrates rescue, recapitalization of Prospect Medical Holdings' Rhode Island hospitals
- Indiana bars autism therapy provider from Medicaid billing: Wall Street Journal
- UnitedHealth shareholder sues over proposal to include details on integration in annual proxy
- SCAN taps biopharma, CMS vet Aman Bhandari as its first chief AI officer
- Infosys to acquire Optimum Healthcare IT in $465M deal
- Healthcare systems can create AI care pathways with new Viz.ai tool
- DOJ alleges NewYork-Presbyterian forces payers into anticompetitive 'all-or-nothing' contracts
- FDA Warns Biotech Firm Over Cancer Drug Anktiva Claims
- Bees and Hummingbirds May Be Consuming Small Amounts of Alcohol
- Two States Sue Cord Blood Company Over Misleading Claims
- New WHO Guidance Aims To Speed Tuberculosis Testing
- As questions swirl around ATTR competition, Alnylam plots path to market leadership for Amvuttra
- Trump admin delays nomination for new CDC director past deadline
- Outspoken ACIP member steps down amid vaccine panel uncertainty: reports
- Egg-based drugmaker Neion Bio emerges from stealth to cook up multi-product biosimilar collab
- Genentech walks the walk in lupus as sponsor of annual awareness and fundraising event
- Study Reveals How Many Americans Consider Using a Gun
- Massive Study Finds Stress and Grief Don’t Cause Cancer
- Ultra-Processed Foods Harm Fertility In Both Men And Women, Studies Reveal
- Small Daily Habits Can Add Up To Better Heart Health
- Ritalin Might Protect ADHD Kids' Long-Term Mental Health, Study Finds
- Can You Drink Enough Fluids To Prevent Kidney Stones? Maybe Not, New Study Says
- Clasp, loan-linked hiring tool for employers, clinches $20M to expand amid federal loan caps
- Taking a GLP-1? Doctors Say Not To Forget About Movement and Mental Health
- OpenEvidence rolls out AI medical coding feature
- CDC’s Acting Chief Promises a Return to Stability in a Tumultuous Moment
- Remarks at the Financial Stability Oversight Council Meeting
- RWJF: Between 5M and 10M people could lose Medicaid coverage in 2028 under work requirements
- New therapy animal program aims to support 100K patients, providers
- Pulse check on Lilly's GLP-1 fortunes
- Gen Z nurses prioritize schedule flexibility, need more manager interactions to avoid turnover
- How pharma marketers can capitalize on HCPs’ AI, social media and streaming habits
- Federal Officials Investigate States That Require Abortion Coverage
- Corcept's lead drug bounces back from FDA snub with different approval as Lifyorli in ovarian cancer
- Ionis slashes Tryngolza's price tag by 93% ahead of anticipated label expansion
- FDA approves Denali's Hunter syndrome drug, handing rare disease community a win
- Baby Walkers Sold on Amazon Recalled Over Fall Risk
- Want To Protect Your Brain? Science Says Exercise
- HelloFresh Pizza Recall Issued in 10 States Over Metal Risk
- Clinical Trials Have Too Much Data…That’s the Problem.
- Clinical Trials Have Too Much Data…That’s the Problem.
- CMS reveals new Medicaid model that supports coordination for children with complex needs
- Novartis sued by breast cancer patient over branded drug websites’ data-sharing practices
- Takeda targets $1.3B in cost savings in further restructuring
- Biogen pays $20M upfront to tap into Alteogen's subQ delivery tech
- 'Universal Donor' Blood Supplies Dangerously Low, Study Warns
- Why Stepping Outside May Help You Eat Better
- U.S. Medicine, Science Facing An Online Misinformation Siege, Poll Concludes
- Childhood Obesity Undercuts The American Dream For Some, Study Says
- Inclusive High Schools Benefit All Students, Not Just LGBTQ Teens
- Parental Loss Due to Drugs, Violence Raises Child Death Risk by 2,000%
- As Boehringer touts US launches, board chairman worries EU is 'falling further behind'
- The evolving state of exome and genome sequencing
- Demoralized CDC Workforce Reels From Year of Firings, Funding Cuts, and a Shooting
- An Arm and a Leg: Steep Health Care Costs Steer Americans to Tough Decisions
- Qualified Health locks in $125M in fresh funding to scale enterprise AI at health systems
- Misery Loves [Investment] Company?: Remarks at the 2026 Investment Company Institute Investment Management Conference
- Study: Nearly 1 in 5 pediatric hospital deaths involve sepsis
- As expansions come online, CDMO Hovione aims to meet industry's 'dual supply and sourcing' zeal: exec
- Opening Remarks at the Digital Asset Summit 2026
- CVS Caremark, FTC reach settlement in insulin pricing case
- UCB unveils plan to build $2B biologics plant near its US headquarters in Atlanta
- PeaceHealth sued over plans to tap out-of-state staffer ApolloMD for Oregon EDs
Who gets to decide sincerity when it comes to 1st Amendment rights?
Standoff on COVID-19 vaccine ended a 22-year careerTim Rugg, an Ann Arbor firefighter for 22 years, says he was fired for refusing the COVID-19 vaccination after being refused a religious exemption. Rugg and three other Ann Arbor city employees have filed a civil lawsuit against the city. Rugg said the reason the city denied him a religious exemption is because the city determined his claim was not sincere.
Ann Arbor implemented a COVID-19 vaccination requirement in August 2021. Rugg said he submitted a religious exemption request shortly after but was refused on the grounds he was not sincere enough in his faith. He said he was suspended without pay in November 2021 and was terminated a month later during a meeting with human resources.
There was no other reason given for Rugg’s firing, according to Noah Hurwitz, his lawyer.
During the termination meeting, Rugg said, two union representatives, his lawyer, and his pastor attended, along with two of the city’s human resource employees.
Rugg’s union went to arbitration and the arbitrator said Ruggs had to undergo a second interview to determine his sincerity. The interview happened on May 15, 2023, with Rugg’s pastor present. Again, the city decided Rugg’s claim was not sincere.
Hurwitz said his law firm is taking on many similar cases. He believes that 98% of employers conducted themselves properly when it came to their COVID-19 policies, including granting exemptions. He also said that some clients say their employers acted inappropriately.
Hurwitz said the city of San Francisco was also sued after it fired employees for what it deemed insufficient sincerity. A district court judge ruled that the employees did not prove their sincere belief, and therefore ruled in favor of the city.
The 9th Circuit Court of Appeals heard an appeal. It remanded the case to the district court, with instructions to the judge to reevaluate the claims “applying the proper failure-to-accommodate inquiry.” The Ninth Circuit court ruled, “It seems that the district court erroneously held that Appellants had not asserted sincere religious beliefs because their beliefs were not scientifically accurate.”
The appeals court said that one’s religious beliefs do not have to be “consistent or rational” to be protected under Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964.
Bloomberg Law said employers who are hasty to deny a religious exemption “may run afoul of federal and state law, creating a liability for employers.”
Bloomberg said that an employee’s religious beliefs do not need to be consistently observed to be deemed sincere. The Equal Employment Opportunity Commission reports that “a sincere religious believer doesn’t forfeit his religious rights merely because he is not scrupulous in his observance, although ‘[e]vidence tending to show that an employee acted in a manner inconsistent with his professed religious belief is, of course, relevant to the factfinder’s evaluation of sincerity.’”
The city of Ann Arbor declined comment, citing the ongoing litigation.
Jamie A. Hope
Assistant Managing Editor of Michigan Capitol Confidential
Jamie A. Hope serves as the assistant managing editor of Michigan Capitol Confidential. She owns a consulting business, and previously worked at the Michigan Legislature as a legislative aide, as well as for the House Republican Policy Office. She is an author and has written for American Thinker and Human Events. Jamie has a bachelor’s degree in business administration from Michigan State University.
Jamie A. Hope may be reached at Hope@mackinac.org.
Newsweek: Religious exemption prevails in an EEOC case in Georgia.
Link to full report includes video.
Hospital Worker Fired for Not Getting Flu Shot Wins Payout
A hospital worker who was fired for refusing to get a shot of the flu vaccine has won a $45,000 payout from the facility he used to work for, according to a press release by the U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC).
The worker, who is unnamed in the press release dated December 22, had asked the hospital—Children's Healthcare of Atlanta, Inc. (CHOA)—in 2019 to be exempted from the facility's flu vaccination requirements based on "sincerely held religious beliefs," something which the hospital allows in its procedures.
Despite the fact that the hospital had already granted the same employee a religious exemption in 2017 and 2018, the following year CHOA denied his request and fired him. This happened despite the employee being a maintenance worker and having little interaction with the public or members of staff, according to the EEOC.
The former employee then filed a religious discrimination lawsuit against the CHOA thriough the federal agency in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Georgia, Atlanta Division, which eventually ruled in his favor.
The EEOC said that the reported conduct of the pediatric hospital "violated Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964, which prohibits firing an employee because of their religion and requires that employers reasonably accommodate the sincerely held religious beliefs of their employees."
The lawsuit will also change the way the hospital considers flu shot exemptions. According to the EEOC, CHOA will have to "presume the exemption eligibility of employees with remote workstations or who otherwise work away from the presence of other employees or patients, and to protect the ability of such employees to seek alternative positions within CHOA if their religious exemption request is denied."
The ruling also requires CHOA to train "relevant employees" on religious accommodation rights under Title VII.
Vaccine mandates are common for health workers, as they are considered to have an obligation towards their patients' safety. But mandatory vaccines have recently become a particularly contentious issue, especially after the COVID-19 emergency.
"It is the responsibility of an employer to accommodate its employees' sincerely held religious beliefs," said Marcus G. Keegan, the regional attorney for the EEOC's Atlanta District Office, in a written statement.
"Unless doing so would require more than a minimal cost, an employer may not deny requested religious accommodations, let alone revoke those previously granted without issue. The EEOC is pleased that the employee has been compensated and that CHOA has agreed to take steps to ensure that it meets its obligation to evaluate religious accommodation requests in a manner consistent with federal law."
https://www.newsweek.com/hospital-worker-fired-not-getting-flu-shot-wins-payout-1855724
MI Cap Con reports resolution of a benefits issue in the Ann Arbor case.
The EEOC civil rights suit appears to be ongoing in US District Court.
Ann Arbor firefighter wins appeal, receives unemployment benefits
Firefighter to get benefits after city fails to show at hearing
Former Ann Arbor firefighter Tim Rugg has won his appeal to receive unemployment benefits after the city fired him in December 2021. Michigan Capitol Confidential previously reported on Rugg’s dismissal, which came after 22 years of employment, for refusing a COVID-19 vaccination.
Rugg had requested a religious exemption from the vaccination mandate, which the city denied, saying he was insincere. The city then denied Rugg’s claim for unemployment benefits, citing misconduct under the Michigan Employment Security Act.
Rugg filed an appeal with the Department of Licensing and Regulatory Affairs. He won a reversal June 19 from Administrative Law Judge Denise McNulty.
Denise McNulty noted that courts have defined “misconduct” as actions that exhibit willful or wanton disregard of an employer’s interests, with an intent to do the employer harm, repeatedly. Rugg disputed the city’s claim he had acted that way. The city did not show up to the hearing McNulty conducted, leading her to rule in his favor. “His unrebutted and credible testimony contained no information of wrongdoing or disregard of the employer’s interest,” McNulty wrote. As a result, she concluded, “The claimant is not disqualified for benefits from the misconduct provision” of state law.
Rugg and three other city employees who were also denied religious exemptions have filed a civil lawsuit against Ann Arbor. They seek a monetary award, including payment for mental anguish and reimbursement for legal fees.
Rugg said his union’s lawyers have tried to negotiate with the city to reverse his termination and reinstate him but have not succeeded.
The city did not respond to an email seeking comment.
Get MHF Insights
News and tips for your healthcare freedom.
We never spam you. One-step unsubscribe.

















