Obama Judge Overturns OBBBA Provision, Refunds Planned Parenthood

A three judge panel of the First Circuit Court of Appeals vacated Judge Talwani’s July orders granting preliminary injunctions blocking the defunding of Planned Parenthood:

https://storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.mad.286600/gov.uscourts.mad.286600.98.0.pdf

Probably will take a few more months to overturn her December injunction blocking the defunding of Planned Parenthood.

Did not even take a month to overturn U.S. District Judge Indira Talwani's December (second) injunction blocking the defunding of Planned Parenthood.  Talwani should be impeached and forced to run for political office to continue her legislative career:

https://thehill.com/policy/healthcare/5668686-planned-parenthood-funding-law/

Court allows Planned Parenthood Medicaid funding cuts in multiple states
by Ashleigh Fields - December 31, 2025

A panel of federal judges on Tuesday lifted a ruling blocking Medicaid funding cuts for Planned Parenthood in multiple states.

The 1st U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals issued a hold on an order from District Judge Indira Talwani that had prevented a law removing funds from Planned Parenthood from being enforced.

The law in question was passed by Congress as part of President Trump’s tax package, commonly known as the “big, beautiful bill.”

That bill restricts Medicaid funding for tax-exempt organizations that provide reproductive services including abortions if they received more than $800,000 in Medicaid funds during fiscal 2023, according to Reuters.

Talwani’s injunction was previously being upheld in 22 states and Washington, D.C.

Planned Parenthood has warned the law could lead to the closure of its facilities.

“We are facing down the reality that nearly 200 health centers are at risk of closure. We’re facing a reality of the impact on shutting down almost half of abortion-providing health centers,” Alexis McGill Johnson, Planned Parenthood Federation of Americas’s CEO, said in a July interview with The Guardian.

“It does feel existential. Not just for Planned Parenthood, but for communities that are relying on access to this care,” McGill Johnson added.

We will post Michigan AG Dana Nessel's reaction to this reversal of Judge Talwani. Nessel joined her secret cabal of Democratic Attorneys General in this law suit.

Some administrative strategy insight.

https://www.dailysignal.com/2026/01/14/why-hhs-restored-planned-parenthood-funding/

Why Trump’s HHS Gave Planned Parenthood Tens of Millions in Funding Back

Elizabeth Troutman Mitchell | January 14, 2026

As some pro-lifers expressed outrage over the Trump administration restoring family planning funding to Planned Parenthood, other pro-life voices say there’s more to the move than meets the eye.

Politico reported that the American Civil Liberties Union on Monday dropped its lawsuit against the administration after the Department of Health and Human Services quietly released tens of millions in Title X family planning funds to Planned Parenthood and other clinics.

The move sparked widespread outrage from pro-life conservatives.

The ACLU, joined by The National Family Planning and Reproductive Health Association, had sued the administration over what they called “unlawful” withholding of more than $65 million in Title X grants to clinics.

But the agency may have had no choice but to restore funding, according to Tom McClusky, a veteran pro-life operative and director of government affairs at CatholicVote.

The agency withheld the funds before amending 42 U.S. Code Part 300, a rule which governs family planning grants.

“They were virtually certain to lose the lawsuit, forcing them to repay the full amount plus interest and cover attorneys’ fees,” McClusky told The Daily Signal.

“Even worse, continuing the litigation would have entangled any future funding cuts—which are highly likely under the new regulations—in prolonged court battles before an unsympathetic judge.”

A former senior Trump administration official told The Daily Signal the administration will now be in a better position to defund Planned Parenthood.

“HHS was caught in a tough spot because the judge was almost certainly going to rule against them and they would have had to restore the funding under Biden era rules, possibly with interest and attorneys fees on top for Planned Parenthood,” the former official said.

“With the case dismissed, the administration has far greater ability to cut Planned Parenthood funds under Trump era rules and that will be the true test of the president’s promise to end taxpayer funding of the abortion industry.”

However, McClusky said none of this would have happened if the administration had restored the Protect Life Rule, promulgated during the president’s first term and rescinded by the Biden administration.

That rule provided that a counselor in a Title X project could “neither refer for, nor encourage, abortion.” The second Trump administration has not reinstated it.

Ethics and Public Policy Center family policy scholar Patrick Brown said there have been examples of pro-life betrayals under the Trump administration, such as the lack of action on the abortion pill, but this move is not one of them.

If HHS hadn’t restored the funding, “Planned Parenthood would have had a much stronger legal case. And the concern there is, not only would they win this one, but it could make future litigation harder to to win,” Brown said.

Last March, HHS informed nine health care providers that it would withhold Title X funding due to “possible violations” of Trump’s executive orders, including one prohibiting groups receiving federal funding from having diversity, equity, and inclusion initiatives.

Planned Parenthood published a memo Nov. 12 saying that since the beginning of 2025, “nearly 50 Planned Parenthood health centers have been forced to close following the loss of Title X funds and Medicaid reimbursements.”

The “One Big, Beautiful Bill Act” removed Medicaid funding for Planned Parenthood.

Hannah Anderson, former deputy chief of staff for policy at HHS, said she is confident that the Trump administration will do “whatever they need to do, and can do to ensure that federal taxpayer dollars aren’t going to these clinics.”

“I think it is absolutely worth it for the federal government to say you have to play by the new rules on DEI and transgenderism, and they’ll either comply or not, and the courts will decide one way or the other,” Anderson, who is now senior director of policy at America First Policy Institute, told The Daily Signal. “But yes, we should be enforcing the rules equally on these facilities.”

The White House and Health and Human Services Department declined to comment for the story.

And the case is over. PP has thrown in the towel.

https://www.dailysignal.com/2026/02/02/defunded-and-defeated-trump-scores-win-as-planned-parenthood-drops-lawsuit-for-tax-dollars/

Planned Parenthood Ends Quest to Restore Half-Billion in Taxpayer Funding

Fred Lucas | February 02, 2026

In a significant legal win for the Trump administration and the pro-life movement, Planned Parenthood dropped its court case to restore federal funding through Medicaid.

Last year, President Donald Trump signed the “One Big, Beautiful Bill” that, among other things, defunded the nation’s largest abortion provider for a full year.

The defunding, though temporary, itself was a long-sought achievement for pro-life lawmakers.

“This is a tremendous victory for the pro-life movement, and the president will continue delivering on his promise to defend life and push pro-family policies,” White House spokeswoman Taylor Rogers told The Daily Signal.

In September, the 1st U.S. Circuit of Appeals ruled to allow the Trump administration to withhold Medicaid reimbursements to Planned Parenthood while the appeals proceed.

On Friday, the plaintiffs—Planned Parenthood Federation of America, and state affiliates in Massachusetts and Utah—dismissed their complaint.

“Planned Parenthood and others have spent months running to court to claw back more than half a billion dollars and subvert the will of the taxpayers, who strongly oppose being forced to fund the destruction of human lives,” Katie Daniel, director of legal affairs and policy counsel for Susan B. Anthony Pro-Life America, told The Daily Signal.

“Abortion businesses are not entitled by the Constitution to taxpayer dollars, and their efforts will not succeed.”

While a win for pro-life supporters, there are separate ongoing court cases involving Democrat-run states defending funding state Planned Parenthood clinics.

Further, unless Congress acts in an additional reconciliation bill, federal funding of Planned Parenthood will resume in July, noted Melanie Israel, visiting fellow at The Heritage Foundation.

“It’s a win for women, girls, and unborn babies when Planned Parenthood gives up its quest to force taxpayers to foot the bill for Big Abortion—over half a billion dollars per year, to be precise,” Israel told The Daily Signal. “We’ve known all along that nothing in the Constitution entitles Planned Parenthood to the American people’s hard-earned tax dollars.”

Pro-life groups have pushed for a full 10-year defunding provision before Planned Parenthood funding returns in July, she said.

“Denying big abortion its big payday doesn’t mean cutting funding for women’s health care generally,” Israel added. “Funding can still go toward real health care providers, including the thousands of Federally Qualified Health Centers and pregnancy resource centers that vastly outnumber Planned Parenthood clinics.”

Last year, the abortion group’s annual report covering the years 2023 through 2024 found it had more than $2.5 billion in net assets, with $792.2 million in government funding. During that time period, the group conducted 402,230 abortions, an increase from the previous annual report that showed 392,715 abortions.

Planned Parenthood has argued that federal dollars do not go to abortions at affiliate clinics, but rather to other women’s health care services. Critics have long noted that the money is fungible.

Planned Parenthood leaders have vowed to fight for funding on other fronts.

“President Trump and his allies in Congress have weaponized the federal government to target Planned Parenthood at the expense of patients—stripping people of the care they rely on,” Alexis McGill Johnson, president of Planned Parenthood Federation of America, said in a public statement.

“Through every attack, Planned Parenthood has never lost sight of its focus: ensuring patients can get the care they need from the provider they trust.”

This story was updated to include a comment from White House spokeswoman Taylor Rogers.